Shoppers no longer trust your discount banner

Shoppers have stopped believing in your discounts. A bigger '30% off' banner won't fix that.
According to Simon-Kucher, as reported by Retail Dive, only 22% of US consumers think advertised discounts reflect true savings. A year ago, the figure was 46%. The survey covered 1,500 adults.
That's roughly half the trust in 12 months (banners all over the place, belief absolutely nowhere).
The same Retail Dive report says 77% of shoppers say inflation has changed how they shop. So people are careful and sceptical. That is a tough mix to sell to.
Careful shoppers will compare. They'll open up other tabs. They'll read the fine print. A discount that looks a bit too good to be true gets a second look and in some cases a very quick exit.
Peak season is upon us. Loads of plans still start with the same question really: how big should the headline discount be?
Why the loud discount stops working
Shoppers have seen 'up to 50% off' so many times that the phrase has lost all meaning. When every single retailer is screaming it, the scream is completely meaningless.
Blanket percentage off has a rather quiet cost in that it treats everyone the same. Some of them needed a little nudge. A lot of them didn't.
Here is what that tends to cause:
- It gives margin to the shopper who was already going to buy.
- It teaches people to wait for the next sale.
- It makes your offer look like the one down the road.
Trust is very difficult to re-establish once it's gone. Every 'blanket' sale is a message to the customer that the full price was never the real price.
The broader evidence points in the same direction. Les Binet's work with Nielsen, reported by Marketing Week, suggests about 84% of price promotions are unprofitable. BCG estimates the share of inefficient retail promotions at 30-40%.
We're not saying stop discounting. Discounts work when they change what the shopper does. Many of them don't.
If you want the longer piece on trust then our post on why deal seekers might not trust your discount is a good one to read next.
Shoppers decide weeks before the sale
There's another issue. A lot of the shoppers have already formed an opinion prior to your banner even going up.
The Pixel, in partnership with Stripe, surveyed 1,000 online consumers, as reported by IMRG. It found that 41% shop on Black Friday and Cyber Monday each year, or most years. Another 40% join in only occasionally. The remaining 19% never do.
The research habits are important. In the same survey 23% start their research 2-4 weeks in advance, 22% start a week in advance and only 6% wait until the day itself. So overall around 56% of BFCM shoppers are researching at least a week in advance.
So intent forms early. A discount that only shows up on the day it's actually there, after the decision has long since been made.
That gives you a to do list. Get your offers page and your email teasers live early. Don't hold everything back until Friday morning.
The occasional shoppers are the interesting lot. They're not the loyalists. They need a reason to do something and a reason to believe it. A bigger banner gives them neither.
What to do instead
You don't need a bigger discount. You need a more believable one, shown to fewer people. Here's a simple starting point:
- Show is only for the shopper who needs an incentive. If you're someone who's ready to buy at full price then you should see full price.
- Say what the offer is, why it's there and when it ends. Plain is better than clever.
- Be visible early. Give the researchers something to find in the weeks prior to the day.
- Measure what the offer changed rather than how many people used it.
Take the first one. One of our shoppers has been on a product page for 10 minutes and added it to the basket. Another one came in via email, looked at one item and walked away. They're not the same shopper.
One might need a nudge. The other might need nothing but a clear page.
Now the final point. Compare the shoppers who saw the offer to a similar group who didn't. If both groups bought at the same rate then the offer was a gift rather than a nudge.
The first point is the one that protects margin. BCG also reports that personalised offers generate 3x ROI. That is the case for targeting in one line.
Fewer, more targeted offers also means you're spending less on promotions as a whole. It's not the same thing as having the same budget spread more cleverly. The saving is in not paying people who would have bought anyway.
Shoppers also want some proof that the deal is worth it rather than just a number. Our post on why peak season shoppers want proof shows you how to provide it.
Prediction beats reaction
Most promotions are reactive. The shopper adds to basket, pauses and then walks away. Then you've got a discount email chasing them.
That's late. The Baymard Institute's average cart abandonment rate is around 70%. By the time you've got round to it, most of those people have already left.
Tempo is our predictive intent engine. It identifies the signs that a shopper is about to abandon their cart whilst they're still on the site. That's precovery - acting before abandonment rather than after.
It also keeps the discount in the drawer when it's not required. Some of the shoppers are now leaving, others are just wandering around with a cup of tea (those two groups are going to need a different approach).
You don't need to build any of this yourself. RevLifter is a managed service. We work with you. The pricing is commission or CPA so we do well when your incremental revenue does.
Before peak season, try three quick checks:
Look at where your discount is actually being displayed. Is it visible to all visitors?
- Look at when it's appearing. Is it only on that day?
- Look at what it's changed. Can you prove it?
None of these checks require any new tools. A spreadsheet and a bit of honest half an hour will be all that is needed.
If the answers are 'yes', 'yes' and 'not sure', you have found your first fix. If you would like a hand, Tempo and Precovery are a good place to start.
Shoppers trust fewer, clearer offers. Show them one that earns it.

